This Pumpkin Pie Shake is the perfect way to use up leftover pumpkin pie. If you don’t have leftover pie, make or buy a pie just so you can make Pumpkin Pie Shakes!
The first time I saw a pumpkin pie shake on a menu, I thought, YUCK! I love my milkshakes, but I don’t like pumpkin pie. And the thought of a piece of pie in a milkshake was just a little too weird for me. Well, I have quickly changed my tune!!
I first saw the idea of a pie shake on the menu at a restaurant in Provo, Utah. They had all different flavors and combos. The first one I ever tried was an Oreo Mint Pie Shake and it was delish. I discovered that the idea of combining a piece of pie and a milkshake was pretty much brilliant. They put the whole piece of pie, crust and all, into the blender with ice cream.
So maybe the idea of a Pumpkin Pie Shake wasn’t so strange after all?!
How to make a Pumpkin Pie Shake
I decided I didn’t want to wait until we had leftover Thanksgiving pumpkin pie to give it a try so I bought a frozen pumpkin pie! First, I baked the pie and then cut it into slices and froze it again. I chopped up the frozen pie and threw it in the blender along with ice cream, milk and blended it up!
Guess what? It is awesome!! Remember, I don’t even like pumpkin pie but a pumpkin pie shake is amazing! For me, it is the texture of pumpkin pie I don’t like but I like the flavor so a pumpkin pie milkshake is perfect.
You can also use pumpkin pie made from scratch. This would be a fun way to enjoy your leftover Thanksgiving pie. But the quick and easy store bought pie is pretty delicious too!
So when you have some leftover pumpkin pie – try something new! Pop it in the freezer and then make yourself a Pumpkin Pie Shake – you won’t regret it!! The possibilities are endless – Banana Cream Pie Shakes, Chocolate Cream Pie Shakes, and Coconut Cream Pie Shakes just to name a few! If you have other pies leftover from Thanksgiving, give them a try too!
Just top the milkshake with some whipped cream, caramel sauce and a little piece of pumpkin pie!
Then grab a spoon and dig in!
Some other favorite ice cream treats:
For all of my other favorite kitchen products and tools visit my Amazon Store.
Pumpkin Pie Shake Recipe
Pumpkin Pie Milkshake
Ingredients
- 2 C vanilla ice cream
- 1 C milk
- 1 large slice pumpkin pie chopped and frozen (can be used unfrozen also)
- Whipped cream garnish
- caramel sauce garnish
Instructions
- Combine ice cream, milk and pie in blender.
- Pulse to blend. Keep in freezer if not serving immediately.
- When ready to serve, stir and scoop with a big spoon into mugs. serve with a dollop of whipped cream, a drizzle of caramel sauce and a small piece of pie as a garnish.
Nutrition
Originally posted Nov. 26, 2008
Get my Weekly Menu Plan for FREE!
Receive my FREE "What's for Dinner?" Meal Planning Course, a copy of my FREE ebook that includes my most popular recipes and my FREE weekly Meal Plan.
That is such a great idea, one I will have to try !! Thanks 🙂
Have a great Thanksgiving too!!
oh.my.goodness. I’ve never heard of pie shakes, but that just sounds DIVINE. I will definitely be making my own pumpkin pie this season simply to try this recipe!! Thx for sharing :>
Even though it’s freezing her in MA, I’m dying to try one of these pie shakes! They look delish, as does the meal from Sammy’s.
WHO has leftover PIE???? Not us!!
We had a house full of college kids last night – ours and some of their friends. They ate their way through a whole batch of snickerdoodles so I pulled the frozen pumpkin pie out of the freezer and made them a couple of batches of Pumpkin Pie Milkshakes and they LOVED them – they were a huge hit!
I LOVE pumpkin pie, so I’m really anxious to try this luscious sounding concoction! 🙂
My mouth is watering sooo bad! Oh I wish I lived by you!
YUM! YUM! This looks fantastic. It is printed off and taped on the refrigerator to try. THANKS!
does this mean you will now trust me about all things delicious? ha ha! glad you enjoyed it. (i’m not a pumpkin pie fan either, but i do like a pp shake.)
i’m dying to try a banana cream pie shake!
rachelle »
I will never doubt you again! Anything you like – I like!
THANKS. I love you Google. I have so much damn pumpkin pie leftover from the holidays, I definitely needed something new to do with it.
This was a winner at my house this Thanksgiving. We hosted a party this weekend with lots of teens to help eat some of our dessert leftovers and while they were skeptical at first about a pie shake it quickly became one of the popular dessert. Thanks Leigh Anne for sharing this yummy treat idea.